Kenilworth
Nub News Logo
Nub News

Why was preferred new Warwickshire police chief candidate dropped?

Local News by Andy Mitchell - Local Democracy Reporter 1 hour ago  
Emma Bond was expected to become the new chief constable of Warwickshire Police (image supplied)
Emma Bond was expected to become the new chief constable of Warwickshire Police (image supplied)
advertisement

Warwickshire's Police & Crime Commissioner (PCC) has confirmed that "evidence from various sources" led him to ruling that Emma Bond MBE was "not suitable" to be the county's new chief constable.

It was announced last week that Ms Bond, named by elected PCC Philip Seccombe as his preferred candidate in June, had had her recruitment process terminated.

She had been due to be presented to the county's Police & Crime Panel – a body of councillors and independent members who would have had to sign off the appointment – in July but confirmation hearings kept getting pushed back.

Those taking top jobs in police forces are unveiled prior to pre-employment checks and Mr Seccombe told Monday's meeting of Warwickshire's Police & Crime Panel that "parts of those subsequent stages took longer than had originally been anticipated", including the work of external bodies.

He acknowledged councillors would have questions over what had happened but said the circumstances "form part of a confidential recruitment and employment matter" and that "it would not be appropriate for me to disclose or characterise them".

"That confidentiality is important to the individual concerned and to the integrity of the recruitment process," he said.

"My immediate priority is to ensure continuity of leadership for Warwickshire Police."

In an interview with the Local Democracy Reporting Service, Mr Seccombe explained that there had only been two candidates in the process to appoint Ms Bond and that fresh processes – one to appoint a new interim to release current caretaker David Gardner to take the chief constable's post at Staffordshire Police, then another process to sort a permanent appointment in Warwickshire – would be prioritised.

Download our Nub News App!

- It’s FREE and available now
- Breaking news notifications
- Your Town in Your Pocket

Mr Seccombe said informing Ms Bond of his decision had been "one of the most difficult phone calls I have ever had to make". He declined to confirm whether there had been any pushback due to her right to appeal, adding he had been given "no indication" on whether she would do so.

"It was my decision on evidence from various sources," said Mr Seccombe.

"This involves people and there could be a legislative process, an appeal, and I would not want to say anything that could prejudice that."

Ms Bond won a tribunal against Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) in 2023 for sex discrimination, due in part to her being moved to a different role against her wishes.

She had previously faced complaints from colleagues after she raised concerns over officers being on standby at home rather than attending for duty during Covid. An independent review found that any accusation of misconduct by Ms Bond could not be upheld.

When asked, Mr Seccombe said he was not in a position to say whether or not his decision related to that.

"My job is a question of assessing risk and with the evidence we have had, I have assessed that she is not suitable to be the chief constable of Warwickshire," he said.

"This is about someone's career. My strong feeling is that I don't want to over denigrate her but I had to make a decision."

advertisement

He added that Ms Bond had been "selected on merit as the best candidate" through a "robust" initial process but "since then, other information has come to me that has made me reverse that decision".

Asked why the issues had not been flagged sooner, Mr Seccombe cited the process.

"I don't agree with it. I don't think it is fair on the candidate, me or anyone else to announce something is going to happen and then it doesn't," he said.

"But in life you have to make the right decisions and this was the right decision."

He described Ms Bond as "a nice person" and stressed repeatedly that "I wouldn't want her to be criticised in any way".

"It has been a difficult few weeks but you have to be able to sleep at night by doing the right thing," Mr Seccombe added.

He was adamant that the outcome had not been as a result of any "negligence or wrongdoing" from his office, putting it down to "the way things have developed".

"My job is to make sure we have an efficient and effective police force and that is what the (future) appointment – temporary or permanent – will be based upon," he said.

advertisement

As for incumbent interim David Gardner, Mr Seccombe said: "For his benefit I hope he is able to go as soon as possible with Staffordshire having selected him.

"We have to agree an exact timing but appointing an interim would release him.

"It is all very amenable. He is our chief constable until he goes so it is not in our interests for me to not be amenable. I think it will work fine, things are smooth and the conversations have been good."

Mr Seccombe indicated it was too soon to put a cost on the aborted process but confirmed it would include funds for the legal advice he has had to take.

In announcing Ms Bond's preferred candidate status in June, the Office of the Police & Crime Commissioner (OPCC) said she was on secondment from Police Scotland to the National Police Chiefs' Council (NPCC) but the NPCC has told the Local Democracy Reporting Service that her secondment was to the Home Office.

Police Scotland and the Home Office have been contacted to offer Ms Bond the opportunity to comment.

Download our Nub News App: - It’s FREE and available now
- Breaking news notifications
- Your Town in Your Pocket

     

Can we count on you? Local news is the heartbeat of Kenilworth
— it needs your support.

For less than the price of a cup of coffee each month,
you can help us keep telling the stories that matter to Kenilworth.
Support local journalism. Protect your community.

Thank you to those of you that have already contributed.
Monthly supporters will enjoy:
Ad-free experience
advertisement

Share:

Comments (0)

Post comment

No comments yet!


advertisement

Downdload our Nub News App:
- It’s FREE and available now
- Breaking news notifications
- Your Town in Your Pocket